Moore divided the arguments against the historicity of the book into three groups. As to the historical value of the foregoing data, opinions differ. For many christians, the book of esther is the basis for a jewish festival that found no counterpart in the christian calendar. When it comes to genre, esther is one of the hardest books to place. Neither its historicity, canonization or message need to be overly scrutinized, as the book of esther displays a depth of historical accuracy, the overt presence of god, and an inspirational message of an enduring faith under the threat of death, all wrapped up within a package of brilliant storytelling. The author also displays an accurate knowledge of persian customs and palaces. This unlikely contestant for a beauty pageant was crowned queen of persia and renamed esther, meaning star. The book of esther is a romantic and patriotic tale, perhaps with some historical basis but with so little religious purpose the book purports to explain how the feast of purim came to be celebrated by the jews. It is clear that the author was a jew, both from his emphasis on the origin of a jewish festival and from the jewish nationalism that permeates the story. The book is never alluded to in the new testament or dead sea scrolls, and even comments about it by the church fathers are rare.
Factchecking best picture nominee selma duvernay has said that her goal was to capture the complexity of every character in the film, including. The human author of esther opens the book with the same hebrew formula. In 2012, a graphic adaptation of the book of esther was illustrated by j. Choose from 500 different sets of old testament books historical flashcards on quizlet. Church, the bridge crossing jubilee advisory board, the black belt african american genealogical and historical society, and a former board member of the long beach museum of art. Controversy over whats fact and fiction in selma film. Business finance education lifestyle shopping books church. Address on courage, at brown chapel in selma, alabama 8 march 1965. The most important names among the more recent defenders of the historicity of the book are perhaps havernick, keil, oppert, and orelli. Intro to esther biblica the international bible society. He apparently intends his readers to think the story he is about to tell relates to actual historical events. Selma does a magnificent job of recreating important historical scenes, such as the events of 7 march 1965 known as bloody sunday in which alabama state troops. More important for the present discussion, scholars retro jected their value system back to ancient israel.
Willow creek megachurch pastor bill hybels preaches on mlk. Historian questions accuracy of selma he says that the film incorrectly portrays president johnson as an obstructionist to the rev. A history of controversy the book of esther is a fascinating story that has a lot of stuff going on that isnt readily apparent to the reader. The great prophets of israel taught us moral, not historical, lessons. We certainly know that many, perhaps most, midrashim were intended to relay allegorical religious messages and not to decsribe historical facts, as commentators such as maharal and maharsha demonstrate at length.
What are some of the historical inaccuracies in the 2014. Dec 26, 2014 the makers of the new movie selma apparently just couldnt resist taking dramatic, trumpedup license with a true story that didnt need any embellishment to work as a bigscreen. James bevel preaches from the book of esther and tells the congregation. This is a great book to use if you need information. In the context of the 1960s, states rights meant the right of individual states to. Although selma is impressive in most of its historical accuracy, it is not meant to be a documentary any more than 12 years a slave or unbroken. Credit atsushi nishijimaparamount pictures, via associated press every oscar season brings with it new charges of historical inaccuracies aimed at contending films be it with the hurt locker or lincoln or this years imitation game. Selma, mordechai and historical truth suburban torah. The movie selma has a glaring flaw the washington post. Questioning the historical accuracy of selma the new york. The events in the book of esther occurred from 483.
The book may have been composed as late as the first. Even though the book of esther claims to be a strictly historical account, ever since j th. Should movies about history actually be about, you know, history. The book is named for the star of the story, a young jewish girl named hadassah who was taken from her guardian, mordecai, and forced to compete for the affection of the king. Much could be said about this topic of course, but based on some of my favorite commentaries, ive identified three influences that, for the purposes of. But it shows clearly that, even when god is most hidden, he is still working to protect his chosen people. Esther, the beautiful jewish wife of the persian king ahasuerus xerxes i, and her cousin mordecai persuade the king to retract. The selma to montgomery march was part of a series of civilrights protests that occurred in 1965 in alabama, a southern state with deeply entrenched racist policies. This essay is taken from mlks book stride toward freedom 1958. Esther is encouraged by mordicai to conceal her jewishness.
Esther, theology of bakers evangelical dictionary of. Selma questions are nothing new for historical films the. On the other hand it does not conform to this genre as it is found in the bible for one main reason. It made it very easy for me to look up specific dates, marches, etc. Although we do not know who wrote the book of esther, from internal evidence it is possible to make some inferences about the author and the date of composition. It is the one book that makes no direct mention of god. Waldman and appeared in volume one of the graphic canon, edited by russ kick and published by seven stories press. Review of the negro freedom movement, compiled in esther cooper jackson ed. Learn old testament books historical with free interactive flashcards. The book of esther and ancient storytelling society of biblical. Book of esther overview insight for living ministries.
The book of esther is a 20 movie starring jen lilley as queen esther and joel smallbone as king xerxes. This is a broad strategy to historical attacks on jewish traditions. Whereas, for instance, the great jewish medieval scholar maimonides 151204 ranked esther. After dealing with several objections to believing the historical accuracy of the setting of esther, gordis summarizes. Robert baralhistorical booksthe book ofesther 1282007 adpage 3 i. Jan 22, 2015 the issue of historical accuracy continues to dog selma, though its hard to gauge how much the brouhaha contributed to the films inability to land best director and actor oscar nods. Even if the story is just a parable, its lessons remain equally strong. Feb 12, 2015 selma does a magnificent job of recreating important historical scenes, such as the events of 7 march 1965 known as bloody sunday in which alabama state troops and local police attacked.
A pair of volunteers, both black, drove the allwhite group from the airport to selma. Archaeology and the book of esther andrews university. I gave this book 5 stars becuase it is a great research tool and it tells the story of selma in 1965 very well. Historical background the book of esther may be placed historically between the events recorded in ezra and nehemiah. Comparatively few modern scholars of note consider the narrative of esther to rest on an historical foundation. The historical and political issues in selma world. Recent movies, such as selma which highlights martin luther king and the civil rights movement have rekindled the debate. Dec 30, 2014 colman domingo, left, david oyelowo, andre holland and stephan james in selma. Esther is an entertaining historical story that also reveals important truths about how and why the jews survived such an overwhelming threat. Opinion a historical controversy about selma the new.
Her documentary th, which links trumpera america to its racist past, is a hot favourite to win an award published. The blend of these literary features with a historical setting and a theological purpose, however, suggest that the genre of the book of esther is unique to itself. Chestnut later cowrote in his book, black in selma, the march to montgomery was the first enterprise id ever seen involving black. A talented, though indifferent, student, 18yearold haley bypassed college, and on the eve of world war ii enlisted in the u. There is nothing close to a consensus, however, as to what historical event provided the basis for the story. Eric f goldman, special consultant to johnson and to his white house office, wrote in his 1969 book the tragedy of lyndon johnson. Ultimately the value of the book of esther, the value of any story historically accurate or otherwise, does not lie in historical truth, but in the lessons we. May 31, 2015 one of the more subtle inaccuracies had to do with the vietnam war. Why does the book of esther refer to mordechai as an. Ava duvernay, the director of selma, chose to portray president lyndon b. Feb 17, 2015 factchecking best picture nominee selma duvernay has said that her goal was to capture the complexity of every character in the film, including king, who is hardly portrayed as a flawless saint. Historian questions accuracy of selma portland press herald.
King is absent from the first selma march, socalled bloody. Even the name of the book, esther, is significant because that name when translated from the persian means somethin. The historicity of megillat esther the aishdas society. It is true that we have no external sources corroborating the nucleus of the incident described in esther. Selma is 100% historically accurate but imitation game. Admit its historical character and all is easywe have an adequate cause assigned for the visible effects. For the curious thing about the book of esther is that, although it has all the hallmarks of a romance, with its string of coincidences, its artfully told narrative, and its engaging characterisations, it can at no point be unequivocally faulted on historical grounds which cannot, incidentally, be said in the least of the greek book of esther. The makers of the new movie selma apparently just couldnt resist taking dramatic, trumpedup license with a true story that didnt need any embellishment to work as a bigscreen. For duvernay, and those in her camp, historical truth is a secondary. Selma does a magnificent job of recreating important historical. But first i need to point out that the issue under question is the historical accuracy of the book of esther, not the related midrashim. On the other hand, there is nothing intrinsically impossible or improbable in the central incident.
God is not mentioned by name in the book of esther. Sep 17, 2012 today we continue our series, esther actually, with a look at the cultural, historical, and religious context that produced the book of esther. All of us know about esther s peculiar difference from the rest of the bible. Jan 20, 2015 the historical and political issues in selma by fred mazelis and tom mackaman 20 january 2015 the 50th anniversary of the historic 1965 march from selma, alabama to the state capital of montgomery. Unlike daniel, there seems to be no concern on the part of esther to keep the dietary laws. Duvernays last film, selma, was overlooked at the oscars. On the one hand it is written as a historical narrative with intimate knowledge of the persian court. You wouldnt be able to pop into a drugstore today and buy a sheamoisture or curl theory product if it werent for the multimilliondollar brand madam c. Some may respond that the book can be true even if it is not historically accurate. Shea in this study of esther for the anchor bible series, c. The film captures this gruesome assault quite accurately and.
On the contrary, it possesses many of the characteristics of the modern short story, with fastpaced action, narrative tension, irony, and reversal. In 1965, dr martin luther king jr led a campaign in selma, alabama, to secure. Coast guard, where he would serve for the next 20 years. The great prophets of israel taught us moral, not historical. Willow creek megachurch pastor bill hybels preaches on mlk, selma, bibles queen esther taking stand. The book of esther takes place in susa modern day iran in the court of a persian king, xerxes or ahasuerus. When king is speaking at the funeral of jimmie lee jackson, he criticizes johnson for waging a war in vietnam while ignoring the struggles of black americans.
1523 319 991 99 580 660 1115 1454 23 807 831 1469 1489 1263 743 380 1295 1029 215 163 780 115 497 1047 725 387 995 1537 1496 1321 275 925 687 77 157 280 1152 993 1323 1201 1057 1195 1450